Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

Legislature debates mask bill

  • 0

A bill that would make it a crime to hide behind a mask during a protest faced constitutional questions during a North Dakota legislative committee hearing Tuesday.

House Majority Leader Al Carlson, R-Fargo, told the House Judiciary Committee that his bill “relates” to the monthslong protests over the Dakota Access Pipeline in Morton County, but it would apply to other demonstrations as well. The bill would make it a Class A misdemeanor for somebody to intentionally conceal their identity by wearing a mask, hood or “other device that covers, hides or conceals any portion” of their face while appearing on a roadway or on public property, or while holding a demonstration on private property unless the property owner gives written permission.

The bill includes several exceptions to the prohibition, including for people wearing a traditional holiday costume in season or while defending themselves from the elements.

Carlson said the mask bill would help ensure the safety of peaceful protesters as well as law enforcement officers. He cited instances of protesters cutting razor wire and burning tires.

“I would be the first to defend your right of free speech and freedom of assembly,” he said. “I’m always concerned when there’s a reason that, I believe, may be used to hide your identity when you’re creating some kind of disturbance.”

Jennifer Cook, policy director for the American Civil Liberties Union of North Dakota, said House Bill 1304 is unconstitutional and called it “overbroad and vague.” She said the exceptions listed in the bill wouldn’t withstand constitutional scrutiny because they would favor certain kinds of speech.

“The U.S. Supreme Court has consistently interpreted the First Amendment to shield a broad and expansive array of speech,” Cook said in prepared testimony. “Expression does not only come in the form of the spoken word, but also in the intentional expression of an idea through expressive activities.”

While she asked the committee to give the bill a “do not pass” recommendation, Cook said it should at least be amended to reflect a “narrowly tailored” Honolulu ordinance that prohibits the use of masks to evade identification “in the commission of any criminal offense.”

Carlson said the bill was drafted by looking at what other measures across the country have “stood the test of time.” Still, he acknowledged the proposal is controversial because it has First Amendment implications.

“Not every state has upheld it,” Carlson said. “But it was one tool that we didn’t have in our toolbox that I think should be required.”

The mask bill is one of several pieces of legislation introduced this session that addresses the protests over the $3.8 billion pipeline, which was delayed by the Obama administration but may have a brighter future under President Donald Trump. On Tuesday, he directed federal agencies to expedite review and approve the nearly complete pipeline.

The project was met with opposition from the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, which worried that its water supply would be tainted if the pipe leaked. Its crossing under Lake Oahe has been the focal point for the protests that have drawn people from across the country and resulted in more than 600 arrests since August, the Morton County Sheriff’s Department said last week.

Morton County Sheriff Kyle Kirchmeier attended Tuesday’s hearing but did not testify. Afterward, he told Forum News Service that it’s common to see protesters wearing masks during what he described as riots, making it harder for law enforcement to identify people who have allegedly committed crimes.

Rep. Todd Porter, R-Mandan, a cosponsor of the mask bill, said the state hasn’t had to deal something like the Dakota Access Pipeline protests before.

“I think that it’s very much our job and very much our responsibility to bring forth measures and laws that have been directly identified as an issue during this situation,” he said.


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

After more than 50 years of providing care to the elderly and others, operators of a nursing home in southwestern North Dakota will soon close their doors for good. The Good Samaritan Society home in Mott plans to close in July, leaving families of its residents searching for new senior living options. Good Samaritan Society-Mott staff met with families about the closure and provided a list of the closest nursing homes. Its executive director, Phil Samuelson, said that the pandemic has put stress on the senior care industry. Samuelson said in a statement that staffing challenges, a decline in residents and increased operating costs also contributed to the decision to close the facility.

Secretary of State Al Jaeger has denied a move by group that wants to change the voter threshold for amending the state constitution. Jaeger said in a letter to the sponsoring committee Monday that nearly 6,000 of the signatures were invalid. The sponsoring committee last month delivered 910 petitions with a claimed 33,624 signatures, just over the 31,000 signatures that must be approved to get the proposed measure on the November ballot. Jaeger says just under 26,000 signatures were legitimate. The citizen-led Protect North Dakota’s Constitution wants to require voter approval of constitutional amendments from a simple majority to 60% and limit a measure to a single subject. The group said a dozen constitutional amendments proposed since 2010 have been successful.

The South Dakota attorney general’s office is not charging billionaire and philanthropist T. Denny Sanford following an investigation into the potential possession of child pornography. The state prosecutor’s decision was made public in court filings Friday. Sanford is a philanthropist who made his fortune in banking, and has given billions to hospitals, universities and charities. South Dakota investigators in 2019 began searching his email account, as well as his cellular and internet service providers, for possible possession of child pornography. Sanford’s lawyer has said the investigation revealed that his client’s email accounts were hacked. The Department of Justice declined to comment when asked if Sanford remains under federal investigation.

Authorities and family members said a 28-year-old woman was arrested after police found her 6-year-old son’s body in the trunk of her car in a Minneapolis suburb. Orono police said the woman and a man were arrested on suspicion of murder after the boy’s body was found Friday. They haven't yet been formally charged. When officers stopped the car in Mound, Minnesota, they noticed blood inside the vehicle. Police have not yet released details about the boy or the circumstances of his death. Family members said the boy’s father was trying to win custody at the time of his death. The boy had been placed back with his mother in December after nearly a year in foster care.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News