Bill seeks to stop court cases with no North Dakota ties

2013-02-20T15:00:00Z Bill seeks to stop court cases with no North Dakota tiesBy NICK SMITH | Bismarck Tribune Bismarck Tribune

The Senate Judiciary Committee heard testimony on a bill that deals with the treatment of out-of-state parties in North Dakota civil litigation.

House Bill 1042 would change the state’s court venue requirements for civil cases. HB1042 would require that if none of the defendants live in the state then the case must be brought forward in one of two places. Those two places would be either in the county where one of the plaintiffs resides or where the cause of legal action originated.

Rep. Lawrence Klemin, R-Bismarck, testified in favor of HB1042.

“This venue requirement applies equally to both resident and nonresident plaintiffs and will prevent forum shopping by both resident plaintiffs and nonresident plaintiffs,” Klemin said.

Klemin said the only changes to the venue requirement would involve cases in which no plaintiffs or defendants are from North Dakota and the cause of legal action didn’t occur in the state.

“The issue of venue arises mainly because of the asbestos litigation that has been pervasive in North Dakota and over the entire United States for the past 20 years,” Klemin said.

Klemin cited the case of Vicknair v. Phelps Dodge Industries. He said this case began in 2002 and took nine years of litigation, including coming before the state North Dakota Supreme Court twice. Klemin said the case involved 15 plaintiffs from Louisiana who sued 135 defendant companies.

“None of these plaintiffs had anything to do with North Dakota or any North Dakota company,” Klemin said. “They sued in North Dakota because they had missed the statute of limitations in Louisiana and North Dakota has a longer limitations period.”

Louisiana’s statute of limitations for such civil action on tort actions is two years, Klemin said. In North Dakota it’s six years.

The case was thrown out in 2011 by the Supreme Court.

“If we’d had the venue requirement contained in HB1042 the plaintiffs wouldn’t have been able to use the North Dakota courts for their litigation,” Klemin said.

Klemin said HB1042 would keep the state from taking on such cases. With the growing court caseloads statewide litigation of such cases with no North Dakota ties would only further stretch the courts, Klemin said.

No one spoke in opposition to HB1042, and no action was taken on the bill Wednesday. HB1042 was introduced by Legislative Management through the interim Judiciary Committee.

Reach Nick Smith at 250-8255 or 223-8482 or at

Copyright 2015 Bismarck Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

First N.D.-made drone rolls out Friday

On Friday, the first unmanned aerial system — commonly referred to as a drone — manufactured in North Dakota rolled out its Wahpeton manufactu…

May 22, 2015 3:45 pm

Military leaders mark Memorial Day with ceremonies

Military leaders mark Memorial Day with ceremonies

North Dakota National Guard officials expect at least a few thousand people to attend its Memorial Day ceremony Monday at the state veteran’s …

May 22, 2015 2:30 pm

N.D. lawmakers still no closer to session decision

With less than six weeks left in the biennium, state lawmakers and the North Dakota Public Employees Retirement System are still waiting to he…

May 21, 2015 8:41 pm

Renovations, new features added to Lions Skate Park

Renovations, new features added to Lions Skate Park

The third time is a charm for upgrades to the Lion's Skate Park near the Hillside Aquatics Center in Bismarck. That's how many times it took t…

May 21, 2015 5:45 pm

Lawmakers to whittle interim studies

Lawmakers to whittle interim studies

The groundwork for the 2017 legislative session begins Wednesday when Legislative Management meets in Bismarck to whittle down a list of more …

May 21, 2015 5:30 pm

Senators aim to expand human trafficking bill

In an effort to give health care workers the tools to identify and protect victims of human trafficking, U.S. senators Heidi Heitkamp, D-N.D.,…

May 21, 2015 4:45 pm

Featured Ads

View All Ads