North Dakota House OKs deadly force bill

2007-02-11T18:00:00Z North Dakota House OKs deadly force billJONATHAN RIVOLI/Bismarck Tribune Bismarck Tribune
February 11, 2007 6:00 pm  • 

The North Dakota House narrowly approved a measure Monday to allow homeowners greater latitude in using deadly force on intruders.

Known as the "Castle Doctrine," the measure removes the homeowner's legal duty to either retreat or try to force an intruder to retreat before using deadly force.

It passed 50-44 after a long, lively debate on the House floor and will now be considered by the state Senate.

Proponents of the law say it's not right for homeowners who use deadly force to face the ordeal of being arrested and the burden of proof in court that their actions were in self-defense.

Rep. Alan Carlson, R-Fargo, said many of these encounters occur in a split second. He said it's unreasonable to expect homeowners to determine an intruder's intentions and either retreat or force a retreat in this time frame.

"Some people would have some severe consequences to themselves and their families if they couldn't defend themselves," Carlson said.

Rep. Lawrence Klemin, R-Bismarck, said the change is reinforcing a basic right that goes back thousands of years.

"This is nothing new,' he said. "It goes back to biblical times."

To legally use deadly force, homeowners must have "a reasonable fear of imminent peril of death or serious bodily injury," the bill says. This is established if the intruder is breaking in or if the user of deadly force has reason to believe that a break-in occurred.

The doctrine also applies to a person's office or car, in the case of a carjacking.

It does not allow deadly force to be used on any entrant who has a legal right to be there or on a child or grandchild who is a dependent of the homeowner. The right is also disallowed if illegal activity is occurring at the home or if the intruder is a law enforcement officer serving a warrant.

Opponents of the measure called it an unnecessary change that could result in more shooting deaths in North Dakota.

"This bill is a policy shift where we're going from the preservation of human life to removing that language," said Rep. Stacy Dahl, R-Grand Forks.

Rep. Kenton Onstad, D-Parshall, called it the "shoot first and ask questions later"bill.

"The use of deadly force is avoidable," he said. "This is saying its OK."

Fifteen other states, including South Dakota, have passed "Castle Doctrine" laws in various forms.

The nickname comes from a similar provision in English common law that states "one's home is one's castle."

(Reach reporter Jonathan Rivoli at 223-8482 or

Copyright 2015 Bismarck Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

No Comments Posted.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Burn ban remains in effect, rain expected

Though fire conditions have improved since earlier this week, when a sizable grass fire burned at least 2,000 acres in south Bismarck, Burleig… New

8 minutes ago

School frustrations mount over testing glitches

Every morning this week, Bismarck students had trouble logging online to take the state's new standardized test. Updated: 7:51 pm

6 hours ago

Bismarck accepts detailed flood plan

Bismarck accepts detailed flood plan

In response to a spring ice jam flood in 2009 and Missouri River flooding caused by higher releases from Garrison Dam in 2011, the Bismarck Ci… Updated: 7:48 pm

7 hours ago

House sends income tax bill to governor

The North Dakota House seized on a final opportunity this session to pass an income tax bill by approving the last bill still alive by a nearl… Updated: 11:11 pm

8 hours ago

Oil tax bill introduced, quickly slammed

Oil tax bill introduced, quickly slammed

Republicans unveiled a bill Friday that would permanently enact a flat tax if a large oil tax trigger in state law kicks in in the coming mont… Updated: 6:14 pm

8 hours ago

School district names new principal for Horizon

School district names new principal for Horizon

Bismarck Public Schools has announced Tabetha Rabenberg of Urbandale, Iowa, as the new Horizon Middle School principal. Updated: 8:18 pm

8 hours ago

Featured Ads

View All Ads